Jeff McCormack

Putt's Rum Bar · The Shelf

Featured Rum: Appleton Estate 12 Year Old Rare Casks

November 1, 2026

When the evenings get cool, the bar reaches for something with a little age on it. This month's featured bottle comes from home: Appleton Estate, in the Nassau Valley of St. Elizabeth, where they have been making rum since 1749.

The 12 Year Old Rare Casks is blended by Joy Spence, who became Appleton's master blender in 1997 and was the first woman to hold that title in the spirits industry. Every drop is aged in Jamaica, and the tropical heat means the barrel works faster here than it would in Scotland or Kentucky. That is why a 12-year-old Jamaican rum drinks with so much depth.

What to expect, by Appleton's own description: orange peel, cocoa, vanilla and toasted oak, with a long, warm finish.

How to serve it at Putt's: neat, or with one cube of ice. A rum this age doesn't need a mixer, and it certainly doesn't need cola.

Pair it with: a piece of dark chocolate, or a slice of Jamaican black cake if anybody's grandmother is baking early for Christmas.

Your turn: what's the bottle on your shelf this month? Send it to info@jeffreymcc.com.

From the archive: Putt’s Rum Bar, 2019 · Back to the bar